Saturday, September 3, 2011

The Taj Mahal Hotel and the Terror Attacks

(1) Taj Mahal Hotel
Over one year ago a pretty significant terror attack happened here in Bombay.  It was no 9/11-Two Towers catastrophe, but not because the terrorists did not want it to be.  Most reading this probably remember the attacks carried out by these terrorists at the Taj Mahal Hotel on November 28.  The reason they attacked the Taj Hotel is because it is the most expensive hotel in India and for the terrorists, it represented western opulence and decadence… and an opportunity to strike fear into the hearts of "white people" the world over. Their message: "we will find you in your richest hotels; nowhere is safe.”
(2)
What most do not know is that the Taj Hotel was only one of eight coordinated attacks upon Bombay that day.  The terrorists had planned to kill over 5,000 people and they attacked in South Bombay, Chhatrapati Shivaji Terminus (train station) Oberoi Trident, Leopold Café, Cama Hospital, Nariman House, and the Metro Cinema. 
According to Peter Foster, who published an article on this subject: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/india/3529804/Bombay-terror-attacks-Why-the-Taj-Mahal-Hotel-was-chosen.html, the National Security Guards were brought in and they were quite effective at ending the violence, but not so effective at minimizing collateral damage.  A local on the ground said that western Special Forces go in with SWAT teams and snipers, while Indian Special Forces solve their terror problems by blowing $%@^ up.  They did exactly that.  They named it Operation Black Tornado and unleashed their fury upon the Pakistani members of the Lashkar-e Taiba—a terrorist organization centered out of Pakistan.  The result was that 295 people died; among those were six Americans.
(3)
As stated, their goal was mainly the Taj Hotel and the surrounding area, as they were targeting a very specific demographic that frequented the hotel; those people being: India’s leaders, politicians, white tourists, foreign investors, and the country’s new economic heavy hitters.
I explained all this because we are staying exactly one block away from the Taj Hotel and that is why the managers of the guesthouse we arrived at were being such sticklers about not letting us stay there.  It just so happens that the terrorists stayed in these very kind of guesthouses and were coming and going at all hours (like us) and they kept adding new people into the rooms at all hours (like our group had been doing) and because of these factors, new rules were created for travelers to more easily track them and their whereabouts.
(4) The Taj as it Stands Today
I want to be clear that this area is not dangerous.  It has not been dangerous in the past and is not a dangerous place to be right now.  Like New York, it was randomly attacked and that attack does not make New York or Bombay inherently more or less safe than they were before the attacks.  The goal of terrorism is the leverage of fear: for a minimal price they get a maximum bang for their buck.  Terrorism’s mission is to change the psyche into thinking violence is just around the corner when statistically, nothing could be further from the truth.  
(5) The DC Snipers
Think back a few years ago in Washington D.C.; Steven Levitt, author of Superfreakanomics, pointed out that in a typical year, D.C. experiences fifty murders.  In 2002, however, that average stayed the same but ten of those murders resulted from shootings that caused panic to set in, ultimately paralyzing the entire area in fear.  The culprits were two men acting as snipers, picking off random individuals from the back of their car.  They were domestic terrorists and their ten coordinated attacks did not change the average death toll in the area for the year, but because they were coordinated, everywhere felt as they were the next to die.  It is psychological warfare and it plays to our darkest fears that tell us: "the world is not safe and you are about to die."  That is, in part, why we visit some of these places; we wish to confront those very fears.

(6)
But I digress: as it was, Chad—the leader of the OutDoor Program, Annie, and I were looking for breakfast and accidentally wandered into Leopold Café.  We sat down and found out this was the very same café that had been attacked on that fateful day.  The place has been restored, for much of the damage came from the Indians blowing up the terrorists, but they left the bullet holes and a shattered bullet-ridden window as reminders of the carnage and as a pull for tourists to frequent their establishment. 

I bet the terrorists never counted on Robert Merton’s economic Law of Unintended Consequences: the terrorists wanted to drive fear into the hearts of travelers and scare them away from India, which, in turn, would hurt India’s economy and its already poor population.  However, the terrorists inadvertently turned on a whole new generation of travelers onto the already famous spot.  The bullet holes now drive dumb tourists like me to a place where mafioso figures and backpackers the world over had been frequenting for decades.  The Taj Hotel has also been remodeled as most of its bottom floor was destroyed; they are open for business again as well.


Reporting from Bombay and one of the largest cities in the world...






No comments:

Post a Comment